So, two friends and myself just finished the Simon the Sayer skeleton key room, and only one of us got anything. We couldn't talk to Daniel after the battle, nothing except 72 EXP. The third person got amazing loot (including the Polterpooch), coins, and was able to talk to Daniel. Anyone else have this problem? We were disappointed, to say the least, especially how hard I worked to get a Stone Skeleton Key.
This only makes me laugh and relive terrible memories. I did the Brandon quest in Polaris, the Make-A-Wish quest, and I wasted 1000 crowns on minions, and about 2 hours of my time, only to get a treasure card. I asked Kingsisle to lower the difficulty or fix the drop rates, but they told me it is rare to get items anyways. I think this is ridiculous honestly, and I share your pain.