You will not get credit for this quest if you are beguiled when he dies. This happened to me once before. I fought him again and made sure i wasn't beguiled when he died.
So recently I was defeating Ponce de Gibbon with three friends. However, after I defeated him, my quest still said I needed to.
Since I had already attempted (and failed) to solo him before, there was no "enter" part of the quest.
I defeated, with a Wooly Mammoth, him on the turn where he uses Beguile as part of his cheat.
On a strange note, the Mammoth hit 2013 damage, and after the battle I had 2013 health.
I also defeated the minions that appeared after the battle due to people porting in. (I entered the sigil myself)
Haley MoonHeart Archmage (84) Thaumagture
Just a regular glitch. Doesn't really happen often from Ponce De Gibbon. I kinda got the same thing. I was training my noob with level 85 and then when I needed to go back to talk to Shalek The Wise, he wasn't there so I have to restart the dungeon.
So recently I was defeating Ponce de Gibbon with three friends. However, after I defeated him, my quest still said I needed to.
Since I had already attempted (and failed) to solo him before, there was no "enter" part of the quest.
I defeated, with a Wooly Mammoth, him on the turn where he uses Beguile as part of his cheat.
On a strange note, the Mammoth hit 2013 damage, and after the battle I had 2013 health.
I also defeated the minions that appeared after the battle due to people porting in. (I entered the sigil myself)
Haley MoonHeart Archmage (84) Thaumagture
Same problem with me, but on Pirate101 the Presidio. I had already beat it, though. I was helping my friend Clever Ethan Mickleson, level 7 swashbuckler. I helped him to finish the Presidio. When we got back to Frogfather, it said he hadn't finished it yet?