I have a alt character that had the Penny Dreadful quest from the commons. I finished fighting the different mobs and was supposed to meet her back in the commons to turn in quest. After this quest part (I have done it before on 5 other characters) I go talk to Zeke and he has me return to her to find her diary - and then shes in the dark cave area to give her the pet cyclops to which she says she is allergic and gives it to you.
It seems with the new patch she has been removed from the commons and I have this dead quest in my quest log I can't turn in or get rid of. Could I get some help on this? Where did she get moved to, if at all? And can this old quest still be turned in with her? Is there anyway someone can delete the quest from the quest log if not? I am a completionist - doing all side quests in every world on all my characters - and having this extra quest sit in my quest log.. well it is going to drive me bonkers tbh.
I have the same problem. I have had several accounts before in which I have completed her quests, but when I went to find her on my new profile, she was missing, even though the quest finder told me she was in her normal spot. I hope this gets patched soon. I enjoyed having the cyclops pet a lot.
To play with two of my friends, I made a new character and we got to the first quest you receive from Penny. She was there for the two of them, but not for me. Is there a bug right now with her? I know she's side quest and I know that she goes away and you need to find the book. This is for the very first interaction with her, she was there for my 2 friends, but not for me.